Max Climb & Turn

[FastEddieB]

Well, in a steady state climb, are you not at 1g?

I would think that only if you were accelerating upwards - i.e. increasing your rate of climb - that there would be any effect on stall speed.

Right?

And I'm wondering if turning flight would not, in theory, have some small effect on Vy.

Reasoning? Turning flight maks the plane "heavier", and I thought weight affected Vy.

Went to Google for confirmation and found this:

"Generally, an increase in weight will reduce the maximum rate of climb but the airplane must be operated at some increase of climb speed to achieve the smaller peak climb rate."

Source: http://avstop.com/ac/flighttrainghandbo ... mance.html

That said, I think the difference in speed would be negligible for any reasonable bank angle in the climb, and could likely be ignored. I, for one, have never adjusted for it, though of course I adjust for gradually decreasing Vy with altitude.

Anyway, good question!

[drseti]

Yes, of course, a bank increases load factor and stall speed, and decreases rate of climb. But I don't think the speed at which max climb occurs will change, just the rate of that climb.

[FastEddieB]

Yes, of course, a bank increases load factor and stall speed, and decreases rate of climb. But I don't think the speed at which max climb occurs will change, just the rate of that climb.

What do you think of: "...must be operated at some increase of climb speed to achieve the smaller peak climb rate." (italics mine)

Time to dig out Aerodynamics For Naval Aviators?

[designrs]

I'm going to do some climb and turning climb tests in terms of performance.
Will post results.

[CTLSi]

......

[CharlieTango]

As long as the ball is centered you are coordinated you won't stall.

No, that's not right. As long as the ball is centered, you are coordinated; you won't spin. Certainly you can stall. You stall every time you land properly (hopefully, with the ball centered). And you practice stalls all the time, with the ball centered!

As long as the ball is centered both lift and turn are stable. In pattern turns, ball center is even more critical considering how slow and low the plane has to be...

On climb=out ascent or base to final turn decent if the ball is not centered the high wing may stall before the lower wing at speeds above stall speed, for example.

As a rule of thumb, having the ball centered eliminates the above surprise, and leaves just the task of making sure to keep the speed above stall speed. In other words, cllimb-out at Vy and not Vx.

Here is an article on uncoordinated stalls: http://apstraining.com/blog/2009/10/12/ ... rn-stalls/

You cannot defend the indefensible. A centered ball does not provide stall protection, stall protection comes from maintaining a non-critical angle of attack.

The high wing isn't more prone to stall then the low wing if the ball isn't centered, don't you think it matters which way the ball is off?

Climbing at Vy vs Vx is a matter of objective, best rate or best angle with Vy having more margin until it meets Vx.

As long as the ball is centered both lift and turn are stable.

Huh?

[designrs]

Climbing at Vy vs Vx is a matter of objective, best rate or best angle with Vy having more margin until it meets Vx.

Good point to Vy when turning for extra safety margin unless Vx is absolutely required.

[SportPilot]

.......

[drseti]

So, does that mean that if the tree isn't a simulated one, you don't have to use Vx?

[SportPilot]

.......

[drseti]

And that is the right attitude!

[FastEddieB]

And that is the right attitude!

I thought we were supposed to keep politics out of this!

[drseti]

When it comes to aviation safety, Eddie, even liberals embrace a conservative philosophy.

[SportPilot]

.......

[dstclair]

BTW -- Load Factor actually decreases in a stabilized climb although it is a somewhat trivial amount since it is related to the sin() of the angle (while Load Factor is related to the Cos() of a bank). A 10 degree climb will only reduce stall by around 2% (10 degrees equals around 60 kts Vx/Vy and 1000 fpm climb).

So for all practical purposes one can assume Load Factor is constant for climb in a light plane.