There is a big misunderstanding about what a sport pilot is. Instructors please read the PTS introduction the FAA has required the examiners and CFI's to administer. If any one is training someone and recommending them to the examiner for a checkride at the "novice" level, this needs to be fixed by the instructor and examiner. This is a problem. Students should demand to be trained to "demonstrate mastery of the aircraft" as stated in the PTS introduction (see below) before their checkride.
There is no difference in the piloting skills between a private or sport pilot in the PTS standards. Private pilots are simply trained with additional tasks such as night flying, VOR and airspace. They both must fly that aircraft with the same stick and rudder skills.
I have a direct comparison of the PTS standards word for word, task by task at:
http://sport-pilot-training.com/private ... specifics/
So there is no misunderstanding here it is from the PTS page 13 the CFI and Examiner must go by:
Initial Check—Sport Pilot—Satisfactory Performance
Satisfactory performance of TASKs to meet the requirements for sport pilot certification are based on the applicant’s ability to safely:
1. perform the TASKs specified in the AREAS OF OPERATION for the certificate or privileges sought within the approved standards;
2. demonstrate mastery of the aircraft with the successful outcome of each TASK performed never seriously in doubt;
3. demonstrate satisfactory proficiency and competency within the approved standards;
4. demonstrate sound judgment in aeronautical decision making/risk management; and
5. demonstrate single-pilot competence in an aircraft with a single pilot station (if applicable).
The following are typical areas of unsatisfactory performance and grounds for disqualification.
1. Any action or lack of action by the applicant that requires corrective intervention by the examiner to maintain safe flight.
2. Failure to use proper and effective visual scanning techniques to clear the area before and while performing maneuvers.
3. Consistently exceeding tolerances stated in the Objectives.
4. Failure to take prompt corrective action when tolerances are exceeded.
Please --- all CFI’s, Examiners, pilots and students train and be trained to be the master of the aircraft as we are all required.